Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More Menu (Update 2026)

Cool's Upper Crust serves a mouthwatering selection of subs, pizzas, and more, all with a focus on freshness and flavor. From sizzling hot subs to refreshing salads, the menu offers 30 tempting options.

Popular items include the chicken bacon wrap and pepperoni roll, both made to order and perfect for those on the go. The Italian sub shines with layers of premium meats.

Grab a hearty Cool's Club Melt or cool off with a Southwest Chicken salad. Each sub and salad is designed to satisfy different cravings without breaking the bank, with most items priced around $8.30.

HOT SUBS
COLD SUBS
SALADS

Featured Dishes

BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Taco Pizza
Taco Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More Menu image 1
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More Menu image 2
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More Menu image 3
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More Menu image 4
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More

Cool's Upper Crust Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking into Cool's Upper Crust, you feel the warm, family-owned atmosphere that invites you to kick back and indulge. The straightforward decor highlights the focus on good food without any distractions.

Take-out is the primary option here, allowing you to enjoy meals at home or a nearby park. The aromas of freshly baked subs waft through the air, making mouth-watering promises and making it impossible to resist trying a bite.

This cozy spot captures the spirit of Hamilton, where good food and community ties intertwine.

Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More

About Cool's Upper Crust Food and Specialties

Cool's Upper Crust specializes in delicious made-to-order sandwiches that keep locals returning for more. The hot subs category features decadent selections like the Bacon Lovers and Cool's Spicy Italian that intrigue spicy food lovers.

Cold subs like Barb's Special and Tuna Salad offer refreshing alternatives when you crave something lighter. Each item is prepared fresh daily, ensuring superb quality in every bite.

The restaurant also caters to a variety of tastes with their complementary salads, such as the Taco and Chopped Chicken salad, providing healthy yet satisfying options.

Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More

Cool's Upper Crust is committed to serving fresh and high-quality food, with every meal made to order. This dedication ensures that customers walk away satisfied with every bite. The specialty items, including the chicken bacon wrap and pepperoni roll, showcase the creativity of the kitchen, combining classic flavors with contemporary twists.

The vision reflects a strong community connection, as the restaurant aims to be more than just a place to eat.

By focusing on quick service without sacrificing quality, Cool's invites diners to experience the comfort of home-cooked meals in a fast-paced world. Each dish served carries the care and tradition of family recipes, making Cool's a staple in the Hamilton food scene.