Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More

Discover Cool's Upper Crust in Hamilton, IN, offering delicious made-to-order subs, pizzas, salads, and more. Enjoy family-owned comfort food with favorites like chicken bacon wraps, pepperoni rolls, and Italian subs. Take out only!

Welcome to Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More

Experience the finest dining

Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More

Cool's Upper Crust, located in Hamilton, Indiana, invites you to indulge in a delightful array of subs and pizzas crafted with care. This family-owned gem, situated at 7725 S Wayne St, showcases a menu that caters to sandwich lovers and salad aficionados alike. With an average price of just $8.30, Cool's offers great value without compromising quality. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty hot sub like the Cool's Club Melt or a fresh salad like the Southwest Chicken, there's something for everyone.

Cash only, this take-out establishment prioritizes convenience and taste. Plus, the popular chicken bacon wrap and irresistible pepperoni roll make ordering hard to resist. Gather your friends and family, and explore what Cool's Upper Crust has to offer; it’s the perfect spot for a quick meal or a casual family dinner.

Cool's Upper Crust excels with a concise yet diverse menu, proudly featuring 30 delightful dishes, including 17 hot subs, 5 cold subs, and 8 refreshing salads. The hot subs range from the classic Italian to the mouthwateringly spicy varieties, ensuring each bite packs a punch. Prices are wallet-friendly, averaging $8.59 for hot subs and $7.80 for cold subs.

The family atmosphere permeates every corner, making each order feel personal. Cool's boils down the choices to make ordering easy, yet satisfying, with favorable options tailored to diverse tastes.

The restaurant also places high importance on quality and freshness, ensuring that everything—from meats to produce—is prepared daily. Well-known favorites like the Buffalo Chicken and the Chopped Chicken salad never disappoint, offering both taste and nutritional value.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

7725 S Wayne St, Hamilton, IN 46742, United States

Phone

+1 260-488-2005

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More
Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More

Cool's Upper Crust isn’t just another sandwich shop; it’s a slice of the community, dedicated to serving delicious food in Hamilton, Indiana. Open for take-out only, this establishment focuses on providing a quick and satisfying option for people on the go. The menu boasts an impressive 30 items that cater to a variety of tastes and preferences.

With an average price that hovers around $8.30, eating here is budget-friendly, appealing to families and busy professionals alike.

The hot sub category features classics like the Hot Ham Special and the Bacon Lovers sub—a perfect choice for those who crave a meaty feast. For a refreshing option, the cold subs such as Barb's Special and the Tuna Salad keep customers coming back.

The salad section holds its own too, with options like the Southwest Chicken salad providing a healthy but hearty choice.

One standout aspect of Cool's is its unwavering commitment to quality and family values. As a family-owned business, it ensures that every meal feels like home. Patrons will find that friendly service and a sense of camaraderie are staple features, turning a simple meal into a delightful experience. Visit Cool's Upper Crust, and you’ll not only enjoy great food but also a warm welcome that embodies the spirit of the community.

Cool's Upper Crust - Subs Pizza & More

Cool's Upper Crust stands out with its distinct exterior, clad in warm colors that invite customers to stop by. The take-out focused layout means there’s no sit-down area. However, the patio outside offers a cozy ambiance. The charm of Hamilton infuses the location, where locals often gather for a quick bite and friendly conversation. This vibrant vibe carries through to the interior with simplicity and a welcoming atmosphere, reflecting the family-driven mission of the restaurant.

The hustle and bustle of a busy service adds to the lively character. With customers eagerly awaiting their made-to-order meals, the air fills with the delightful aroma of freshly baked subs that makes every visit memorable.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday10 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday10 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday10 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday10 AM-8 PM
  • Friday10 AM-8 PM
  • SaturdayClosed

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

We are regulars. You can't go wrong here but the Bacon Lovers Sub, Cool's Spicy Italian Sub, Pepperoni Roll, Guido Roll, all Salads, Crazy Dough (add Pepperoni) are my favs! We are lucky to have them in Hamilton

S
Sarah W.

Cash & take out only. Lovely local sandwich shop for a quick bite. Short wait, no longer than a chain. Affordable, good options for sandwiches, salads or wraps. Took it to local public park to eat. Will return if ever back in town.

M
M K.

The wife and I tried cool's for the first time today. We ordered the buffalo chicken sub and the cool's club melt sub. We were very impressed! As both an avid bbq pit master and a food connoisseur i must say that everything about the subs were phenomenal from the buns to everything in between! You guys hit the flavor profile right on the money! Keep up the great food and the great service! My only complaint is that I wish that the subs were bigger because i'm a fat boy but I also know how outrageous the cost of thing's in today's economy are, meat, produce etc, so I get it. I'm also a pizza junky and I will definitely be back to try one!

D
Derek J.

Great little family owned Pizza place !! Thanks to our granddaughters that told us about Adam's Pizza !!! We got the meat lovers yesterday, LOVED IT !! Breadsticks were great too !!

S
Steve C.

We LOVE the food here. Everything we have tried has been top notch! Fast service and amazing owners and staff. We drive from Ashley and it's a perfect restaurant for small town Hamilton! Our favorites are chicken bacon ranch sub, Cools club melt sub, and all the pies!!

B
B B.

We got pizza here and lemme just say-it was fabulous! Just scrumptious.

L
Lydia T.